A blog by Patrick Crozier

Kelly Affair

August 20, 2003

Semantic grape slicing anyone?
Patrick Crozier

Janet Daley is finding it tough going at the Kelly Enquiry:

Well, do you believe him? Or are you so lost in the semantic grape-slicing that you no longer know what it would mean to believe anybody?

Some of the questions being particularly difficult:

This is more than semantics. It is metaphysics. When does a document become a dossier?

Yes, we're getting lost in the details. My guess is that we'll never get at the truth not least because half the participants wouldn't know what the truth was if it stood up and kicked them in the groin.

So, what we are left with are perceptions and the one that I think will carry the day is that both the BBC and the government are distinctly dodgy.

Which is fine by me.

August 11, 2003

Dr Kelly's rules
Patrick Crozier

In a generally good article, John Keegan, himself a former civil servant writes:

All civil servants are subject to the service's disciplinary procedures and code. One of its most stringent articles forbids communication with the media. Indeed, at regular intervals, we were reminded in writing of the ban and Dr Kelly must have read the warning as often as I did.
Which would be cut and dried if it wasn't for the fact that since coming to power the government has continually thrust officials into the limelight. Could it be that Kelly found himself in the position where the rules said one thing but his line manager was saying something completely different? Incidentally, this if a phenomenon which seems to be on the increase. Or is it my imagination?